May 29, 2021
Welcome, God and All...
This well-known quote (well, to my generation, anyway) from the 1967 motion picture Cool Hand Luke has been on my mind lately. It seems to particularly apply to one of the dearest things in my life, Holy Mother Church. You'd think by now I'd just chalk it up as 'one of those things' and bear it among some of the crosses in life I should quietly bear. I have...but I also have something of a sense that this contributes to the problem.
The sense of a lack of communication runs through the entire spectrum. That is, it's in nearly everything the Church touches. If your experience is different, you have my attention. Someday you'll have to tell me how it's working for you. As a minister, it can be frustrating at times.
I know that local parishes have to deal regularly with the irregularity of deaths within the congregational family. Parish funeral planners have a very short timeframe in which to contact ministers and to meet representatives of the deceased's family to select hymns and scripture readings for the funeral Mass. On some occasions we get to the afternoon before the Mass before we know what has been chosen. I'll cut the planner(s) a little slack because they're dealing with grieving family members who are possibly in a state of shock and confusion about the whole process and the many details those grieving family members have to arrange including the funeral Mass. That's par for the course, but communication issues run deeper than that.
Annually, the parish staff has to plan for the seasons of Advent/Christmas and Lent/Easter; and for the celebrations of First Holy Communion, and the celebration of the Sacrament of Confirmation, when the diocesan Bishop (or his designate) visits the parish. I wonder how much and how early priority is given to arranging all of the details. With the sacred days of the Pascal Triduum it's particularly tricky. Will new converts be received into the Church? How is the order of service properly executed? Who takes responsibility for having the right people or objects in the right place at the right time? How much time do they need in understanding their role(s) so that the liturgy runs smoothly?
Now lay the effects of the pandemic on top of this. It seems that the decision to shut down in mid-March last year was made quickly, but how well was that decision made and how well was it communicated? Now that it appears we have survived the worst of it, how well is the message of okay, it's time to come back now being conveyed? What remains different? What precautions should remain in place for those yet unvaccinated, especially children? Or those immuno-compromised? Will they get the wrong message when their diocesan bishop ends the dispensation from required attendance at Sunday Mass?
But hang on, dear reader. The real issue runs deeper than this.
Our Church is meant to run with solidarity. The bishops act in collegiality and communion with each other and with the Pope. If you've happened to follow anything coming out of the Church these days, you will note that there's not a lot of unity. German bishops want to allow same-sex marriage (or at least to bless their secular union). There are groups lobbying for married and even female clergy. And when we start dealing with the Church's hot-button issues - abortion, euthanasia, immigration, religious liberty, environmental stewardship - Pope Francis says one thing, some bishops and priests say another, and many try to avoid saying anything at all.
In just the last week or so, Fr. Michael Pfleger was cleared of abuse charges and will return to his pastorate at St. Sabina Church in Chicago. Those charges were reported in January, so it seems that this was resolved quickly when compared to Australia's Cardinal Pell or America's Theodore McCarrick. Pfleger's case got a lot of attention here in Chicago because of the unique position he's held for nearly the entire length of his priestly ministry - as a white priest and activist in an African-American parish.
Meanwhile, a conservative priest and pastor in LaCrosse, Wisconsin, has been ordered to resign by his diocesan bishop. Fr. James Altman has been quite vocal about how liberal thought and policy are destroying the Church and the fabric of society. Fr. Altman has gone on record against receiving the COVID vaccines. (They have only been approved for emergency use; thus they are considered experimental and anyone taking them is acting as a 'guinea pig'.) He has also gone on record saying that one "cannot be a Democrat and Catholic" - which makes sense, considering the over-the-top political agenda the current administration and Congress are pushing. Compare this to Jesuit priest Fr. James Martin, who is pushing for acceptance of the LBGTQI+ lifestyle as well as gender identity? I don't hear of any superior in the Church suggesting he resign.
Why is it only four of the approximately 300 bishops of the United States made a public point about the promotion of morally obtuse policy by Catholic politicians, particularly President Biden and House Speaker Pelosi? Didn't our Lord Jesus Christ command that they should speak boldly? Do they fear that what happened to John the Baptizer (The Chosen's "Creepy John") could happen to them? In spite of Jesus' frequent reminders of "Be Not Afraid"? (By the way, the call to speak boldly in defense of the Gospel is something all Catholics are enjoined to do.)
So, when all is said and done...and I know the teachings of the Church we honor this weekend and next are difficult to explain; that we give ourselves to ONE God in THREE distinct 'Persons'; and that Catholics believe on faith that the full, True, and Real Presence of Jesus Christ - Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity - exists in the form of the consecrated unleavened bread and wine. But if we are having this much trouble communicating - if the message isn't strong and clear about what I've written in the last six paragraphs - how can we come to believe in what this last paragraph (and don't forget the commands to "Love one another" and to evangelize) contains???
And...lest I forget...how well do we listen???
Discuss...and, until we meet again, may God be with you - and may God have mercy on us all...
+the Phoenix